+1
Excluded

Automatically unassign users from groups

Videoarts 9 months ago updated by Francisco López (Team Leader) 3 months ago 5

In NetexCloud, currently you can enrol users to groups by using assignment rules, but if someone's parameters change and the rules no longer apply to them then they are not automatically taken out of the group.

For example, if you have a Manager group based on Job Title = Manager rule and a user is changed from a Manager to another job role then they should not be in the Manager group any more.

Answer

Answer
Excluded

EN

Hello, 

Our Product Owner answerer regarding this improvement:

Although we find them very interesting. Due to the performance problems generated by the current logic of the allocation rules we are not going to undertake any new type of development in this area.

In the future, we will work on the concept of "self-managed groups" where assignment rules will add or remove users who comply or fail to comply with such rules. However, this development is not in our nearest roadmap for the reasons stated above.

Regards,
/Saray

The improvement remains excluded from our roadmap, sorry for any inconvenience.

ES

Hola

Nuestra responsable de producto respondió acerca de esta mejora:

Pese a que nos parece muy interesante. Debido a los problemas de rendimiento generado por la actual lógica de las reglas de asignación no vamos a acometer ningún nuevo tipo de desarrollo en este área.
En el futuro, trabajaremos en el concepto de "grupos autogestionados" donde las reglas de asignación añadirán o quitaran usuarios que cumplan o dejen de cumplir tales reglas. Sin embargo, este desarrollo no está en nuestro roadmap más próximo por los motivos expuestos anteriormente.

Saludos,
/Saray

El improvement permanecerá excluido del roadmap, sentimos las molestias.

We've had this query a number of times from clients and on sales calls. It would be great if this could be addressed. 

The interface very rapidly becomes messy / cluttered for the end-user as redundant / irrelevant groups & their associated Channels fill up the screen.

Good morning,

We are investigating this improvement suggestion very carefully. Although we do think that the possibility of remove users automatically when the configured rule does not apply anymore is interesting, the feature was originally designed to support different functionality as we also need to think about those users that might be added manually to the same group. 


If we just automatically remove users when the rule does not apply, manually adding users to those groups will become also a real mess and almost an impossible task. 

As soon as we come up with a simpler and clearer design that also includes the suggestion, we will inform you how we will proceed with this topic.

Best regards,

/Saray

+1

Thank you Saray. This would be a standard part of automatic enrolment in many LMS's. It can sometimes be overruled manually (as you point out) but that manual override (at least in larger organisations where the HR data is accurate) is an unusual case.

Answer
Excluded

EN

Hello, 

Our Product Owner answerer regarding this improvement:

Although we find them very interesting. Due to the performance problems generated by the current logic of the allocation rules we are not going to undertake any new type of development in this area.

In the future, we will work on the concept of "self-managed groups" where assignment rules will add or remove users who comply or fail to comply with such rules. However, this development is not in our nearest roadmap for the reasons stated above.

Regards,
/Saray

The improvement remains excluded from our roadmap, sorry for any inconvenience.

ES

Hola

Nuestra responsable de producto respondió acerca de esta mejora:

Pese a que nos parece muy interesante. Debido a los problemas de rendimiento generado por la actual lógica de las reglas de asignación no vamos a acometer ningún nuevo tipo de desarrollo en este área.
En el futuro, trabajaremos en el concepto de "grupos autogestionados" donde las reglas de asignación añadirán o quitaran usuarios que cumplan o dejen de cumplir tales reglas. Sin embargo, este desarrollo no está en nuestro roadmap más próximo por los motivos expuestos anteriormente.

Saludos,
/Saray

El improvement permanecerá excluido del roadmap, sentimos las molestias.